I feel like the Rancor-handler in that Star Wars movie, watching his man-eating pet get crushed under the door, or the guys in the Conan movie that get all bent out of shape because Conan hacked the head off their giant pet snake. You read the monster books carefully, looking for that special critter you just need to have, "I choose you, White Dragon", and then you make it a special home in the dungeon, plenty of food, water, you arrange for all the necessary comforts - like a giant pile of soft coins for nesting - and then *they* come along, and wreck it all. Adventurers.
It's the day after the carnage; now the coffee tastes too bitter, the sunlight is weak, and I have this hollow feeling that used to be filled with joy knowing a monstrous white dragon was lurking in the dungeon ready to spring a TPK at any moment. Now it's dead. Sure, there will be other monsters, other boss fights. There's more fish in the sea. I get it. The monster books are full of hideous travesties to challenge even the doughtiest adventurers. I even told myself I wouldn't cry. It's just hard to say goodbye, White Dragon.
So what did *they* do, to bring me to this low point? I'm glad you asked.
Things started out well enough last game - the party was exploring some new areas in the southeast of the current dungeon, they stumbled on some rooms filled with Black City Radium (a glowing green poisonous rock), they fought a group of green, glowing, radiation zombies, and got exposed to a heavy dose of the green stuff - in fact, over half the group is going to start suffering from a wasting disease that will be fatal in like 1-6 months, losing charisma and the ability to heal, along the way.
The Patriarch of Constantinople, in far away Byzantium, has been at war with Himerius, the High Hermite of Constantinople, a known arcane dabbler and summoner, such that the Patriarch sent a higher level witch hunter (Andronicus Priscian) with a party of hand-picked clerics and a troop of Byzantine spearmen to track the party's Russian elves and magic users, who were all known associates and disciples of Himerius… these trackers followed them to Thule, and have been closing in on the party for a while, and finally accosted them deep in the dungeon. Last night. Then the party killed them. (I should have called it a night then).
The players decided it was time to mess with the Ice Cave itself - besides, most of them were infected with radiation sickness, anyway, and that made them feel like taking risks. The Ice Cave is down a long, 20' wide tunnel, growing progressively colder and blocked with giant icicles and stalactites along the way. Beyond these barriers is a misty cave with walls of solid ice, and an unimaginable pile of coins. One of the recent items the party had recovered was a "wand of telekinesis" and they hoped one of the magic users (Dominicus) could weave his way through the obstacles, get close to the cave, and use the TK wand to surreptitiously lift a chunk of treasure out of the cave without breaking the giant icicles blocking the way.
It was a good plan, except that that they had a dozen characters tromping along with armor in their group, along with an over-sized robot that rolls forward on noisy treads which grind against the stone floor. In other words, they're not exactly quiet. The inhabitant of the ice cave, an adult white dragon, was awake. The rest of the party stood a good 50' behind the barriers of ice, unable to see Dominicus, but they did see a horrible blast of cold spray plume out of the area. Dominicus was flash frozen, brought to -40 hit points or so instantly. The robot was sent to smash through the icicles and pillars of ice and engage the dragon, while most of the fighters and other characters ditched into a side passage, to be out of the line of effect of any more ice blasts. A few (foolhardy) range-attack characters stayed in the main hall, waiting for a chance to shoot into the cave once the robot had cleared the way.
The dragon and robot smashed their way through the ice, and the dragon started tearing the robot apart with claw and tooth, while the robot punched it a couple of times. It had the makings of a drawn-out heavyweight prize fight. And then the players did something totally unexpected… they charged.
It went like this - Brutok: "I'm charging the dragon. Who's with me?" Visin (who adores Agnar): "I'll charge if Agnar charges." Agnar: "Hey, Agnar's not my character, I'm just running him for Mike, who had to miss tonight, so of course I'm with you, Brutok. Let's go!"
The dwarf and two of the fighters rolled high initiative, and sprinted out from around the corner, taking up positions on either side of the robot and laying into the dragon with axes and spears. In the LOTFP rules, a charge does double damage, and the players got it down into a manageable hit point range with a few fortuitous strikes. Once it started using its last two breath attacks, it was far enough down that the breaths were no longer instantly fatal to everyone. The robot was frozen and destroyed, two of the fighters (Agnar and Visin) were dropped to zero hit points, the dwarf is made of hit points and managed to weather a breath attack, Tribunas the magic user made a saving throw and dropped unconscious (but not dead) from half damage, but poor Brick the Halfling was in the line of fire down the hallway, and took a blast directly. He died.
Then the next wave of characters charged, including the two female Norse clerics (queue Wagner's Ride of the Valkyries) and Mustafa. Again, the dragon rolled a 1 for initiative and took a round of beats, dying when Mustafa landed a killing blow. I was… stunned.
I have to give some props to the players, the idea to hide around the corner and charge out at a surprising moment was inspired.
I may need to go back to DM school, to refresh on how to play dragons well as opponents… on a serious note, I do have some observations on the fight I'll put together later this week, a regular post-mortem. Good job fellas, they took down a dragon, losing their uber-Robot and a pair of characters. The clerics had enough healing after the fight to save the three characters that were between zero and -2 hit points (-3 hit points and lower is irrevocably dead in the game). We had to end there as we were already an hour past our targeted end time.
That was Black City Game 21, below is the new and updated "dead list". Hopefully the players can figure out a way to get a half dozen or more Cure Disease spells before too much game time passes, or a lot of folks will get added to the list in the near future when the radiation sickness catches up to them.
- Dominicus: Tried to steal a dragon's treasure… alone. RIP.
- Brick Bunnycracker: Shot in the face with dragon's breath.
- Robbie the Robot: Torn, crushed, and frozen by a dragon. You served them well.
- Bjorn: Shot in the face during an ambush.
- Gareth Bellringer: Possessed by a ghost and marched into a death trap.
- Seamus the Gallic Mage: Died fiddling with the unstable Hyperborean artifact.
- Dag the Unwashed: Blown up by Seamus.
- Uther the Orphan-Poet: Shot in the neck by a bandit.
- Falki Auldason: Killed by a gjenganger.
- Kolfina Ian Svarti: Killed by a gjenganger.
- Irena Edvards: Killed by a gjenganger.
- Molnar the cleric: Lost his grip on a rope and fell into the abyss.
- Arthur the Thief: Killed by a gjenganger.
- Hring the Twig-belly: Covered in oil, burned alive while rats were eating him.
- Herap: Killed by a gjenganger
- Agdi: Possessed by the ghost and marched into the death trap.
- Galm: Infested by a devil wasp and turned into a villain, ultimately dropped down an 80' hole.
A few guys left when they failed morale checks in between adventures:
- Ulf Skullcrusher
- Visin Thorolfson
This sounds awesome, your session updates are really a good time to read!ReplyDelete
"Once it started using its last two breath attacks, it was far enough down that the breaths were no longer instantly fatal to everyone. "ReplyDelete
Is that a LOTFP rule, or had I been playing dragons wrong for years? I always assumed "damage equal to the dragon's hit points" meant hit point score, not current hit points. Is that amended somewhere in the MM or DMG and just didn't notice?
It's in the Moldvay BX rules that the dragon's breath is equal to its current hit points... that creates some interesting tactical choices for the players... speed rush, or evade and wear down, that kind of stuff.Delete
I wasn't happy with the progress of the fight (taking nothing away from the players - they played very well, and my dice were a little cold) but it warrants a little deeper analysis and comparison across editions during the week.
You're not wrong, Peter. It's ambiguous in the original rules, Holmes interpreted it the one way and Moldvay the other, and AD&D kept the ambiguity. I prefer the interpretation that it's based on hit point score, since that keeps the fight extremely tense until the last possible moment.Delete
Or, actually, after checking Monsters & Treasure it's not all that ambiguous: "the value of the breath weapon will be subject to the maturity of the Dragon", with no mention of relation to HP at all. I guess it was Moldvay's innovation.Delete
Interesting. If that was the case - it weakens with the dragon - it would mean a dragon should always open the fight with breath 1-2 times, if not all three. It's like nukes in a nuclear war - use em or lose em. Since claw/claw/bite doesn't degrade, it's worth doing that while wounded but it's too late for breath to help.Delete
Oddly, this would be yet another case (like subdual) where dragons get the shaft that other critters don't. A 1-hp chimera still breathes for full damage.
I've had similar experiences in the past. When a party's going full blast (even a low level party) they can do a lot of damage in one or two rounds, which is often enough to kill even some pretty tough monsters (which actually don't have *that* many hps) in a couple of rounds.ReplyDelete
Maybe it has something to do with this desperate "full throttle" approach from players (throwing off all their best spells simultaneously, using magic items, etc), where in smaller scale battles they tend to be more cautious which thus leads to longer fights.
By the way that LoTFP charging rule sounds way over-powered! I can see it for something with a terrifying weight and momentum behind it -- a triceratops for example, but a 1st level fighter?
It sounds like an awesome fight, and what a sense of accomplishment for the players! The dragon got what was coming to it, feel no sympathy for its alien, reptilian soul.ReplyDelete
Dragons are not robots, and if this one didn't perform with tactical perfection it might be because a) it was suddenly assaulted by tiny ant-like beings in its own lair b) it was being smacked around by a weird robot c) it was actually getting really, really hurt. Playing monsters fairly doesn't really come down to playing them to the hilt, I think - it comes down to playing them as well as you can, subject to your own knowledge and limitations.
When it comes to big baddies getting zerged by the characters of aggressive players, I think it has always been that way. It can backfire in a serious way, and if the players are willing to risk it I see no problem with it. A few bad rolls on their part and they would all have wound up as popsicles...
The Black City Continues to be a pretty amazing Science Fantasy campaign. I much enjoy these play reports.ReplyDelete
Players will always kill your favorite monsters (They did in my phantom cop with buckets of holy water and without a second thought), spare the ones you despise, and then end up dying to something you hadn't even considered (like the critical hit of a dying bandit). What goes around comes around I guess. Still I think the dragon did okay for itself considering the slickness of that attack.
If it wouldn't reveal anything, what surface feature (if any) is above the Ice Cave?ReplyDelete