I ran a poll a month or so back, "What kind of experience do you have with Cthulhu gaming?", and here were the results:
- 17% actively play
- 40% play from time to time and still like the game
- 32% are interested
- 9% either didn't like it or aren't interested
That's quite a bit of overlap in the readership between the two types of games! 91% either play, have played, or are at least interested in the horror gaming; I'll just assume you 9%ers aren't interested YET. I tend to agree there's a lot of overlap; many of the adventure ideas are directly portable from horror gaming into fantasy, and if you go for Weird Fantasy (especially LOTFP style), the horror gaming is like a close cousin.
Cthulhu gaming can be a bit bleak, so maybe it's an acquired taste playing ordinary or mundane folks trying to stop occult horrors, when compared to the accessible power fantasy gaming experienced in the beloved D&D. On the other hand, pulp fantasists like Clark Ashton Smith and RE Howard put Lovecraftian horrors in plenty of their fantasy stories, too, so the chocolate and peanut butter gets mixed up in the source literature.
That raises an important question - how do you like to use the Cthulhu Mythos in your games? As monsters in a fantasy setting, or alien terrors in a horror game? I have added a new poll to catalog the results of this important question! The world must know.
I'll keep up with the weekly Cthulhu posts and occasional reviews, mixing chocolate in the peanut butter and vice versa. It keeps things interesting for me. Bon appétit!
*Image is from the cover of Call of Cthulhu's 5th Edition